Aaron Hill: A Response to Fraser Chinook Measures

June 20, 2020

By: Meghan Rooney

DFO’s management measures announced June 20, 2020 for Fraser Chinook once again fail to protect these endangered salmon runs.

In 2019, the Minister set a conservation objective to limit total mortalities of Fraser Chinook to 5%. The actual mortalities were more than double this amount. This does not take in the additional impacts of the Big Bar slide.

The new measures announced today are not substantially different from last year’s failed measures, even though the stocks are still at-risk. Canada is still not meeting its treaty obligations to the US, and the Big Bar slide is still a major concern. If we want to save these endangered fish, we need to stop killing them.

Of the 13 Fraser Chinook populations assessed by federal scientists, 12 are classified as ‘endangered’ or ‘threatened’. Further, Harrison Chinook, which return to the lower Fraser, have not met their target under the Canada-US Pacific Salmon Treaty in 7 of the last 8 years.

DFO is not doing the monitoring necessary to understand where exactly these endangered fish are being caught in fisheries, and catch and compliance monitoring is sorely lacking in both the recreational and Indigenous fisheries. DFO is also failing to apply its own science in estimating the impact of catch-and-release fishing on the survival of Fraser Chinook.

DFO says they intend to invest in rebuilding, but they do not have rebuilding targets and plans in place as required by law.

In other words, Minister Jordan and DFO decided today to ‘sit on their hands’ and watch the continued decline of Fraser salmon.

Share This Story!

Aaron Hill: A Response to Fraser Chinook Measures

June 20, 2020

By: Meghan Rooney

DFO’s management measures announced June 20, 2020 for Fraser Chinook once again fail to protect these endangered salmon runs.

In 2019, the Minister set a conservation objective to limit total mortalities of Fraser Chinook to 5%. The actual mortalities were more than double this amount. This does not take in the additional impacts of the Big Bar slide.

The new measures announced today are not substantially different from last year’s failed measures, even though the stocks are still at-risk. Canada is still not meeting its treaty obligations to the US, and the Big Bar slide is still a major concern. If we want to save these endangered fish, we need to stop killing them.

Of the 13 Fraser Chinook populations assessed by federal scientists, 12 are classified as ‘endangered’ or ‘threatened’. Further, Harrison Chinook, which return to the lower Fraser, have not met their target under the Canada-US Pacific Salmon Treaty in 7 of the last 8 years.

DFO is not doing the monitoring necessary to understand where exactly these endangered fish are being caught in fisheries, and catch and compliance monitoring is sorely lacking in both the recreational and Indigenous fisheries. DFO is also failing to apply its own science in estimating the impact of catch-and-release fishing on the survival of Fraser Chinook.

DFO says they intend to invest in rebuilding, but they do not have rebuilding targets and plans in place as required by law.

In other words, Minister Jordan and DFO decided today to ‘sit on their hands’ and watch the continued decline of Fraser salmon.

Share This Story!

Stand with us to defend wild Pacific salmon

Stand with us to defend wild Pacific salmon

2 Comments

  1. Ken Pearce June 25, 2020 at 8:06 am - Reply

    as I am sure you are aware of, studies by Chasco et all, Pacific Salmon Foundation, King Salmon fovever, Dr. Carl Walters, UBC, Ben Nelson, UBC and more studies all confirm the consumption of of chinook smolts to range from a low nu,ber of 45% by PSF to a high number by Chasco et all of 85%. Studies show that between hatchery and wild production 50,000,000 smolts are outbound as i write. do the math at the above numbers.
    Also a new study just released show that sea lions on the columbia consume 3 to 5 returning adult chinook/day. estimated in river populations of lions in excess of 6000. gain do the math.
    The band aid solutions set up by DFO will not bring back the chinook with the above consumption. Simply not mathematically possible.
    Ken Pearce PACIFIC BALANCE PINNIPED SOICIETY. We are working with DFO with a plan to harvest the excess pinnipeds.
    stay tuned!

  2. DC Reid June 27, 2020 at 2:09 pm - Reply

    The reality is that DFO has been managing BC wild salmon into extinction for 50 years. Look at this photo of
    Chinook catch from one morning’s fish off the Nahmint River: https://fishfarmnews.blogspot.com/2019/09/v-behaviorurldefaultvmlo.html.

Leave A Comment

Related Posts