Aaron Hill: The election, wild salmon, and the fight ahead

October 27, 2020

By: Meghan Rooney

Aaron Hill, executive director of Watershed Watch Salmon Society

While the final seat tally for B.C.’s election won’t be known until mid-November, it’s clear John Horgan and the NDP will lead a majority government. So what does this mean for wild salmon?

In the previous term under Premier Horgan’s leadership we saw some important accomplishments. At the top of the list was their historic agreement with First Nations in the Broughton Archipelago to remove 17 factory salmon farms. They also partnered with the federal government to launch the BC Salmon Restoration and Innovation Fund and ponied up $27M in watershed restoration funding in their fall fiscal update. And despite its shortcomings, Clean BC is a nation-leading endeavour to tackle B.C.’s greenhouse gas emissions; important because climate change is a massive factor in the decline of B.C.’s wild salmon.

There was also a string of disappointments. In his attempt to develop a “made-in-B.C. wild salmon strategy,” (1) Premier Horgan appointed an advisory council dominated by coastal fishing industry interests. They promoted harmful status-quo fishing practices and an increase in the use of artificial hatcheries, ignoring documented scientific evidence (2) of the enduring risks hatcheries pose to wild salmon. 

The province also failed to deliver a promised species-at-risk law and backed the federal government in their appalling decision not to protect endangered Fraser River steelhead salmon under Canada’s Species at Risk Act.

Under their last term, nothing much changed with respect to logging, mining, pipelines, tankers, fracking, and other activities that threaten salmon habitat across the province. And with massive subsidies for fossil fuel extraction, the greenhouse-gas reductions in their Clean BC plan are going to be difficult or impossible to achieve.

So what about the future? In the run-up to this election, Watershed Watch and many allies pushed hard to get commitments around industrial salmon farming, habitat restoration and watershed management.

The NDP committed to “protect and revitalize B.C.’s salmon populations by building on the successful Broughton process” and to “step up protection of fish habitat through [their] biodiversity strategy.” They also committed to “support innovation in fish hatcheries”; a rather vague commitment but concerning in light of previous comments by Premier Horgan in favour of factory-style salmon ranching, a practice known to harm wild salmon.

In response to our collaborative CodeBlueBC campaign, the NDP promised to “protect clean water in British Columbia by creating a watershed security strategy to plan, manage and protect local watersheds for the public good” and a Watershed Security Fund for “Indigenous, local, and regionally led clean water initiatives” that will “create good, sustainable, local jobs for British Columbians in watershed restoration, monitoring, technology, training, and education.” 

They also promised to “make sure owners of large industrial projects are bonded moving forward, so that they – and not B.C. taxpayers – pay the full cost of environmental cleanup if their projects are abandoned.”

Aside from the hatchery issue, these are good commitments, but so far they are just words. The next step is turning these words into real action. As we experienced over the last three years, we won’t see meaningful action without sustained pressure from you, me and the thousands of people across this province who care about wild salmon and healthy watersheds.

Several of the NDP’s newly-elected MLAs have impressive conservation credentials and should be champions within government for clean water and wild salmon. But it’s the Premier who calls the shots and it’s up to us to hold him and his government to account for the next four years.

We are already pushing hard to ensure that the election commitments are reflected in ministerial mandate letters—the marching orders Premier Horgan will deliver to his newly appointed cabinet in November. And from there we will hound our leaders, and work with them, to make the management and funding decisions that produce real-life results for our fish and watersheds.

 

References:

  1. https://thenarwhal.ca/will-b-c-s-wild-salmon-strategy-be-a-boon-or-bust/
  2. Rand, P.S., Berejikian, B.A., Pearsons, T.N. et al. Ecological interactions between wild and hatchery salmonids: an introduction to the special issue. Environ Biol Fish 94, 1–6 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10641-012-9987-3

Share This Story!

Aaron Hill: The election, wild salmon, and the fight ahead

October 27, 2020

By: Meghan Rooney

Aaron Hill, executive director of Watershed Watch Salmon Society

While the final seat tally for B.C.’s election won’t be known until mid-November, it’s clear John Horgan and the NDP will lead a majority government. So what does this mean for wild salmon?

In the previous term under Premier Horgan’s leadership we saw some important accomplishments. At the top of the list was their historic agreement with First Nations in the Broughton Archipelago to remove 17 factory salmon farms. They also partnered with the federal government to launch the BC Salmon Restoration and Innovation Fund and ponied up $27M in watershed restoration funding in their fall fiscal update. And despite its shortcomings, Clean BC is a nation-leading endeavour to tackle B.C.’s greenhouse gas emissions; important because climate change is a massive factor in the decline of B.C.’s wild salmon.

There was also a string of disappointments. In his attempt to develop a “made-in-B.C. wild salmon strategy,” (1) Premier Horgan appointed an advisory council dominated by coastal fishing industry interests. They promoted harmful status-quo fishing practices and an increase in the use of artificial hatcheries, ignoring documented scientific evidence (2) of the enduring risks hatcheries pose to wild salmon. 

The province also failed to deliver a promised species-at-risk law and backed the federal government in their appalling decision not to protect endangered Fraser River steelhead salmon under Canada’s Species at Risk Act.

Under their last term, nothing much changed with respect to logging, mining, pipelines, tankers, fracking, and other activities that threaten salmon habitat across the province. And with massive subsidies for fossil fuel extraction, the greenhouse-gas reductions in their Clean BC plan are going to be difficult or impossible to achieve.

So what about the future? In the run-up to this election, Watershed Watch and many allies pushed hard to get commitments around industrial salmon farming, habitat restoration and watershed management.

The NDP committed to “protect and revitalize B.C.’s salmon populations by building on the successful Broughton process” and to “step up protection of fish habitat through [their] biodiversity strategy.” They also committed to “support innovation in fish hatcheries”; a rather vague commitment but concerning in light of previous comments by Premier Horgan in favour of factory-style salmon ranching, a practice known to harm wild salmon.

In response to our collaborative CodeBlueBC campaign, the NDP promised to “protect clean water in British Columbia by creating a watershed security strategy to plan, manage and protect local watersheds for the public good” and a Watershed Security Fund for “Indigenous, local, and regionally led clean water initiatives” that will “create good, sustainable, local jobs for British Columbians in watershed restoration, monitoring, technology, training, and education.” 

They also promised to “make sure owners of large industrial projects are bonded moving forward, so that they – and not B.C. taxpayers – pay the full cost of environmental cleanup if their projects are abandoned.”

Aside from the hatchery issue, these are good commitments, but so far they are just words. The next step is turning these words into real action. As we experienced over the last three years, we won’t see meaningful action without sustained pressure from you, me and the thousands of people across this province who care about wild salmon and healthy watersheds.

Several of the NDP’s newly-elected MLAs have impressive conservation credentials and should be champions within government for clean water and wild salmon. But it’s the Premier who calls the shots and it’s up to us to hold him and his government to account for the next four years.

We are already pushing hard to ensure that the election commitments are reflected in ministerial mandate letters—the marching orders Premier Horgan will deliver to his newly appointed cabinet in November. And from there we will hound our leaders, and work with them, to make the management and funding decisions that produce real-life results for our fish and watersheds.

 

References:

  1. https://thenarwhal.ca/will-b-c-s-wild-salmon-strategy-be-a-boon-or-bust/
  2. Rand, P.S., Berejikian, B.A., Pearsons, T.N. et al. Ecological interactions between wild and hatchery salmonids: an introduction to the special issue. Environ Biol Fish 94, 1–6 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10641-012-9987-3

Share This Story!

Stand with us to defend wild Pacific salmon

Stand with us to defend wild Pacific salmon

5 Comments

  1. keith sedar October 27, 2020 at 5:04 pm - Reply

    The only slight glimmer of hope is that Fin Donnelly is back in the race.

  2. Grant Brown October 28, 2020 at 1:18 pm - Reply

    Well written, Aaron.
    Many thanks for the hard work holding these people’s feet to the fire. Politicians are a slippery bunch so it’s not an easy job.
    Clean BC seems (like to many environmental initiatives) to be a marketing catchphrase. As we all know, actions speak far louder than words. Most constituents won’t go much further than the headline. Fewer still will fact check and hold the party accountable.

    Thanks for the important work you do.

    Grant Brown
    Founder, HappyEcoNews.com
    Positive news about the environment

  3. Elke October 28, 2020 at 5:48 pm - Reply

    We live since 25 years next to the Chinook spawning grounds, We have seen the horrible decline in the population. We are witnessing the extinction of a species for the sake of some people making money on fish that is not even healthy to consume for humans. There is no excuse for not acting right away, These farms must get out of the water NOW! Our orcas and other wildlife depends on them. It is a pity and shameful to watch politicians to delay such an important matter! We know how much harm they do so ACT NOW or else it will be very soon to late for it. The shores used to be visited by dozens of eagles and many bears fishing. Not anymore. I have seen 2 eagle sitting on the shore watching the river. NO MORE DELAYS PLEASE!!!! The fish are more important for our ecosystem and if you must talk about making money of it : Tourists from all over the world come each year to get a glimpse of the salmon run. There is no harm but profit, which really that should not ever be the point of doing right by nature…

  4. Don McBain October 28, 2020 at 7:45 pm - Reply

    That should have of course be the “LNG” project.

  5. Andrew Riley October 28, 2020 at 10:08 pm - Reply

    I’ll bet that fish farms are here to stay. Just follow the money. To big for the Federal gov’t whom Horgan will still have to pander too, to make any concrete changes!

Leave A Comment

Related Posts